Faith and the First Amendment

by | May 5, 2008 | 0 comments

When I was told that this issue would focus on faith, I struggled with what to write about. What can a lawyer – raised as a Unitarian with deep-seated values but not participating in any organized religion – contribute to a forum on faith from a legal standpoint? Doesn’t the Constitution require the separation of religion from governmental laws, that is, the separation of church and state?

Then it hit me: It isn’t that simple, much as I might wish it to be. Today, some people use religion to justify governmental oppression of LGBT people, while others use it to support equality under the law for our families. As we work for equality, it helps to understand the complex relationship between the faiths of our citizens and the laws of our land.

The First Amendment to the United States Constitution begins: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof….” The first part, the “Establishment Clause,” means, in its purest state, that the American government cannot have an official faith, unlike England, which takes the Episcopal faith as their official Church.

Ballet - Timeless - 300x300
Division of the arts

The second part, the “Free Exercise Clause,” means that the government cannot regulate religious bodies in ways that hinder them. For instance, they cannot be taxed. Religious bodies are even free to discriminate on the basis of religion at times. Likewise, under both of these clauses, governmental officials must leave their faith at the door: If a judge who is also Christian feels there is a conflict between the government’s law and her faith, she must follow the law rather than her religion’s teaching in deciding the case before her.

On the other hand, the First Amendment does not require citizens to leave faith out of political decisions. We all take our personal experiences, knowledge, and values into the voting booth with us. We each decide how much the moral teachings of a religion should become public policy and how much we should leave room for people to follow a different morality path.

Ballet - Timeless - 300x300
Division of the arts

As Americans, this can be a complex calculation, for while our faith may set certain rules, such as abstinence from alcohol, we also know that our nation comprises people from many religions – as well as people who choose to follow no religion – and our government is designed to allow for that. If we create laws that veer too far from our commitment to the free practice of religion or too close to imposing the beliefs of a particular religion on the general citizenry, those laws will violate the First Amendment to our Constitution.

The Constitution is at the core of what it means to be an American, just as truly as the Bible is at the core of what it means to be a Christian.

How each citizen’s calculation involving American and faith principles impacts LGBT people in the early 21st century is quite significant. In the first half of the 20th century, only a handful of organized religions did not condemn homosexuality outright. Throughout that same period, LGBT people were at best invisible under the law, and, when recognized, they were punished for it (e.g., anti-sodomy laws and laws prohibiting homosexuals from working for the government).

Division of the arts
Ballet - Timeless - 300x300

Laws have evolved over the past 50 years to eliminate most government-mandated discrimination, to require (in many places) equal housing and employment, and (in some places) to grant same-sex relationships some measure of governmental protection.

These significant legal advances happened, in great part, because of growing disagreement among different faiths, and even within faiths, about the morality of our sexualities. Unitarian-Universalist churches are no longer one of the very few places where a same-sex couple might obtain religious blessings. The United Church of Christ, as well as many Presbyterian, Evangelical Lutheran, Jewish, and other religious bodies, celebrate commitments made by same-sex couples. Some even call that bond “holy matrimony,” just as they do for heterosexual couples. That is but one sign that understanding and acceptance of LGBT people and families has been growing within faith communities.

Division of the arts
Ballet - Timeless - 300x300

At the same time, conservative religious communities are pushing back. This year, a strong showing was made by a presidential candidate who stated a desire to amend the Constitution to be “in God’s standards.” In 2006, Bishop Morlino, the highest Catholic official in Wisconsin, instructed Catholics to vote “yes” to amend the Wisconsin Constitution by banning marriage for same-sex couples and anything “substantially similar.” Members of a group called Watchmen on the Walls routinely picket gay pride events and harass gays on the street. One of the group’s leaders, Scott Lively, has been quoted saying, “There is a war that is going on in the world … It’s a war between Christians and homosexuals … And in the United States, … it was the homosexual political movement that designed this strategy to attack Christianity.” In addition, Topeka, Kansas preacher Fred Phelps and his family continue to spew their unique brand of religion-laced hate toward LGBT people.

Ballet - Timeless - 300x300
Division of the arts

The manner in which each of us reconciles our identity as an American with our moral values (religion-based or otherwise) is complex, especially where LGBT rights are concerned. The better we understand this, the better we will fare in our struggle for legal equality and social acceptance. n

Article Tags

Ballet - Timeless - Banner
Advert 77
MGHA tournament

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advert 77
MGHA tournament
Ballet - Timeless - Banner

Latest News

Cash & Olive’s Pub

Cash & Olive’s Pub

Jen O’Branovich and Courtney Sargent of Millie’s Coffee & Eatery in Cambridge have traded in the sunny space they formerly occupied in Galleria 214 to expand into a more Sconnie-style environment outside the main drag.

Pain Is In the Brain

Pain Is In the Brain

Nyle Biondi, MS LMFT, was one of the first out trans therapists in the state of Wisconsin and has devoted the past few years to helping others heal from chronic pain and health conditions.

Be Every Day

Be Every Day

A journey of self-discovery, acceptance, and love decades in the making. Follow along and be inspired at how Martha Marvel discovered her truth.

Queer Joy Book Club

Queer Joy Book Club

A Q&A with the Social Media Administrator, Jamie Butler, about a monthly meetup at the Goodman South Madison Public Library. The Queer Joy Book Club strives to be inclusive by considering books available in the Madison library system that have an e-reader option, an audiobook option, or even a graphic novel.

Latest News

VIEW ALL LATEST NEWS

Division of the arts
Ballet - Timeless - 300x300

Events

SUBMIT AN EVENT

VIEW ALL EVENTS

Jobs

SUBMIT A JOB POSTING

VIEW ALL JOBS

Popular Tags

Pin It on Pinterest